Close

New York Zoning and Municipal Law Blog

Updated:

N.Y. Court of Appeals Rules in Favor Of Cayuga Indian Nation On Failure To Collect Cigarette Sales Taxes

In an action brought to prevent prosecution of members of an Indian nation for failure to collect cigarette sales taxes on sale to non-members of the nation, the Court of Appeals issued judgment in favor of the plaintiffs. In Cayuga Indian Nation v. Cayuga County Sheriff, the court noted that…

Updated:

Court Upholds Denial Of Area Variance Based Upon Balancing Test

The appellate division found that a zoning board properly denied an area variance after engaging in the required balancing test. In Matter of Monroe Beach Inc. v. Zoning Board of Appeals of City of Long Beach the court determined that the zoning board had made findings that: “the requested variances…

Updated:

Court Finds that 82 Year Old Filed Map Does Not Vest Rights to Subdivision

An attempt to circumvent planning board approval of a subdivision using a subdivision map filed in the county clerk’s office 1928 was rejected by the Appellate Division. In Matter of Atlantic Development LLC v. Town/Village of Harrison the court found that a 1923 provision of the local town code, still…

Updated:

Failure to Meet A Zoning Code’s Special Permit Conditions Is Grounds For Denial

An appellate court reiterated the requirement that every precondition to granting a special permit must be met before a zoning board is required to grant such a permit. In Navaretta v Town of Oyster Bay, the Appellate Division Second Department upheld the denial of a special permit by an attorney…

Updated:

Court Upholds ZBA Decision Including Land Under Water in Lot Area

The Appellate Division upheld as rational a decision by a zoning board which included land under water in calculating lot area and floor area ratio (FAR). In Matter of Henderson v. Zoning Board of Appeals the court concluded that: “the ZBA’s determination that both the proposed construction and the subject…

Updated:

Minimal Change In Structure With Approved Area Variance Does Not Justify Denial Of Amended Variances

The denial of an amendment to area variances due to minimal changes in the structure was struck down as inconsistent with the prior decision of a Zoning Board granting area variances. In Matter of Bout v. Zoning Board of Appeals of the Town of Oyster Bay, the Appellate Division noted…